Sự Biến Đổi Các Chỉ Số, Test Trong Tc Nam Vđv Cl Cấp Độ 3 Sau 1 Năm Tập Luyện (N=20)

Nhóm

Chỉ số, test

Ban đầu

x (1)

Sau 6 tháng

x (2)

Sau 12 tháng

x (3)

t1,2

t2,3

t1,3

W1,2

W2,3

W1,3

P

1

Sinh học

HT1

146.763.88

148.253.92

149.733.95

1.203

1.191

2.394

1.005

0.995

2.000

<0.05

2

HT2

52.411.33

53.081.35

53.751.37

1.580

1.558

3.137

1.267

1.251

2.518

<0.05

3

HT4

19.060.84

19.350.86

19.630.87

1.066

1.049

2.115

1.494

1.472

2.965

<0.05

4

SL10

54.651.34

55.231.35

55.811.36

1.363

1.351

2.714

1.054

1.043

2.098

<0.05

5

SL11

157.365.89

159.765.98

162.176.07

1.283

1.264

2.547

1.518

1.496

3.014

<0.05

6

SL12

66.142.68

67.402.72

68.672.77

1.479

1.453

2.932

1.892

1.857

3.748

<0.05

7

SL13

96.053.69

97.513.75

98.983.80

1.246

1.228

2.473

1.513

1.491

3.004

<0.05

8

SL16

10.690.35

10.820.35

10.950.35

1.160

1.152

2.312

1.198

1.184

2.381

<0.05

9

SL17

4.610.21

4.680.21

4.750.22

1.081

1.058

2.139

1.538

1.515

3.053

<0.05

10

SL22

3.380.13

3.420.14

3.460.14

1.001

0.982

1.983

1.267

1.251

2.518

<0.05

11

SL23

49.651.61

50.151.62

50.651.64

0.982

0.971

1.953

1.005

0.995

2.000

<0.05

12

SL27

121.234.78

123.124.85

125.014.93

1.242

1.223

2.465

1.548

1.524

3.072

<0.05

13

SL29

62.592.72

63.742.77

64.892.82

1.320

1.297

2.617

1.813

1.781

3.594

<0.05

14

SL30

6.140.22

6.240.23

6.330.23

1.339

1.317

2.656

1.548

1.524

3.072

<0.05

15

SL31

5.430.19

5.520.19

5.610.20

1.448

1.411

2.857

1.597

1.572

3.169

<0.05

16

SL34

36.111.49

36.731.52

37.341.55

1.294

1.271

2.564

1.691

1.662

3.353

<0.05

17

SH4

12.430.51

12.610.52

12.790.53

1.074

1.056

2.130

1.400

1.381

2.781

<0.05

18

SH6

15.960.75

16.310.76

16.650.77

1.446

1.418

2.863

2.132

2.088

4.219

<0.05

19

SH7

5.410.23

5.540.24

5.670.25

1.709

1.666

3.373

2.332

2.279

4.611

<0.05

20

SH10

1.800.08

1.840.08

1.870.08

1.304

1.286

2.590

1.843

1.810

3.652

<0.05

21

SH11

3.760.09

3.820.12

3.880.14

1.790

1.432

3.125

1.548

1.524

3.072

<0.05

22

SH12

1.350.05

1.370.05

1.390.05

1.156

1.160

2.316

1.449

1.429

2.878

<0.05

23

SH13

23.431.11

23.760.99

24.090.86

0.994

1.131

2.103

1.400

1.381

2.781

<0.05

Nhóm

Chỉ số, test

Ban đầu

x (1)

Sau 6 tháng

x (2)

Sau 12 tháng

x (3)

t1,2

t2,3

t1,3

W1,2

W2,3

W1,3

P

24

Sư phạm

TLC1

5.150.11

5.090.17

5.030.23

1.321

0.930

2.088

1.152

1.165

2.317

<0.05

25

TLC4

85.351.84

84.422.65

83.493.46

1.290

0.955

2.125

1.096

1.108

2.204

<0.05

26

TLC6

7.430.16

7.360.23

7.290.29

1.154

0.866

1.920

0.975

0.984

1.959

<0.05

27

TLCM1

67.201.45

66.551.80

65.912.14

1.242

1.029

2.221

0.960

0.969

1.928

<0.05

28

TLCM2

14.850.32

14.710.45

14.560.57

1.184

0.899

1.987

0.990

1.000

1.990

<0.05

29

TLCM3

7.460.20

7.540.24

7.610.28

1.092

0.912

1.964

1.015

1.005

2.019

<0.05

30

TLCM7

13.960.31

13.830.37

13.700.44

1.221

1.016

2.191

0.949

0.959

1.908

<0.05

31

TLCM9

20.520.44

20.270.67

20.020.91

1.396

0.993

2.227

1.233

1.248

2.480

<0.05

32

TLCM14

25.040.66

25.330.85

25.621.04

1.204

0.970

2.112

1.153

1.140

2.293

<0.05

33

TLCM18

32.630.70

32.320.87

32.011.04

1.229

1.014

2.192

0.944

0.953

1.898

<0.05

34

TLCM19

29.260.63

28.940.88

28.631.13

1.296

0.979

2.168

1.076

1.087

2.163

<0.05

35

TLCM24

90.002.38

91.143.19

92.274.00

1.274

0.990

2.178

1.252

1.237

2.489

<0.05

36

KT1

14.050.37

14.220.45

14.390.53

1.312

1.100

2.366

1.203

1.188

2.391

<0.05

37

KT2

13.240.35

13.400.42

13.560.48

1.314

1.124

2.402

1.198

1.184

2.381

<0.05

38

KT3

6.060.16

6.130.21

6.190.26

1.139

0.909

1.985

1.104

1.092

2.196

<0.05

39

KT4

5.160.13

5.220.18

5.280.22

1.200

0.949

2.077

1.148

1.135

2.284

<0.05

40

KT11

6.060.16

6.140.23

6.220.29

1.328

1.004

2.224

1.351

1.333

2.684

<0.05

41

KT22

6.060.16

6.130.21

6.190.27

1.119

0.875

1.921

1.104

1.092

2.196

<0.05

42

KT23

14.140.38

14.330.51

14.510.64

1.305

1.008

2.219

1.301

1.285

2.586

<0.05

43

CT1

29.710.64

29.420.85

29.141.07

1.199

0.934

2.053

0.965

0.974

1.939

<0.05

44

CT5

6.060.16

6.130.21

6.190.26

1.133

0.905

1.976

1.099

1.087

2.186

<0.05

45

CT6

14.140.38

14.300.49

14.450.60

1.133

0.905

1.976

1.099

1.087

2.186

<0.05

46

Tâm lý

TL1

187.494.05

185.675.39

183.846.73

1.213

0.948

2.082

0.980

0.989

1.969

<0.05

47

TL2

330.767.14

327.609.31

324.4411.49

1.204

0.955

2.089

0.960

0.969

1.928

<0.05

48

TL3

1.730.04

1.750.05

1.770.06

1.208

1.069

2.256

1.054

1.043

2.098

<0.05

49

TL7

3.870.10

3.920.14

3.960.18

1.196

0.898

1.991

1.173

1.159

2.332

<0.05

50

TL9

19.740.52

20.000.67

20.260.82

1.364

1.094

2.385

1.301

1.285

2.586

<0.05

51

TL11

2.410.06

2.440.07

2.470.08

1.426

1.265

2.667

1.252

1.237

2.489

<0.05

52

TL12

0.600.02

0.610.02

0.620.02

1.121

0.967

2.060

1.148

1.135

2.284

<0.05

53

TL13

42.971.13

43.491.52

44.011.91

1.227

0.952

2.095

1.203

1.188

2.391

<0.05

54

TL14

38.851.02

39.301.29

39.751.57

1.216

0.988

2.145

1.148

1.135

2.284

<0.05

W trung bình

1.290

1.277

2.566

Nhóm

Chỉ số, test

Ban đầu

x (1)

Sau 6 tháng

x (2)

Sau 12 tháng

x (3)

t1,2

t2,3

t1,3

W1,2

W2,3

W1,3

P

1.

Sinh học

HT1

161.304.26

162.964.30

164.624.35

1.227

1.215

2.441

1.025

1.014

2.039

<0.05

2.

HT2

57.601.46

58.351.48

59.091.50

1.598

1.576

3.174

1.282

1.266

2.547

<0.05

3.

HT4

20.950.93

21.270.94

21.600.96

1.101

1.083

2.184

1.543

1.520

3.062

<0.05

4.

SL10

60.061.47

60.721.48

61.381.50

1.408

1.395

2.803

1.089

1.077

2.166

<0.05

5.

SL11

172.946.47

175.676.57

178.406.67

1.325

1.305

2.629

1.568

1.543

3.111

<0.05

6.

SL12

72.692.94

73.972.99

75.253.04

1.364

1.342

2.706

1.745

1.715

3.459

<0.05

7.

SL13

105.564.06

107.224.12

108.884.18

1.286

1.267

2.553

1.563

1.539

3.101

<0.05

8.

SL16

11.750.38

11.900.39

12.040.39

1.184

1.176

2.359

1.222

1.208

2.430

<0.05

9.

SL17

5.060.23

5.140.23

5.220.24

1.119

1.095

2.214

1.592

1.567

3.159

<0.05

10.

SL22

3.710.15

3.760.15

3.810.15

1.079

1.058

2.136

1.366

1.347

2.713

<0.05

11.

SL23

54.561.77

55.131.79

55.701.80

1.015

1.004

2.020

1.040

1.029

2.068

<0.05

12.

SL27

133.235.25

135.315.33

137.385.41

1.238

1.220

2.458

1.543

1.520

3.062

<0.05

13.

SL29

68.792.99

69.883.03

70.973.08

1.141

1.124

2.265

1.568

1.543

3.111

<0.05

14.

SL30

6.750.25

6.850.25

6.950.25

1.296

1.276

2.572

1.499

1.477

2.975

<0.05

15.

SL31

5.970.21

6.060.21

6.160.22

1.403

1.368

2.770

1.548

1.524

3.072

<0.05

16.

SL34

39.691.64

40.321.67

40.961.70

1.219

1.198

2.416

1.592

1.567

3.159

<0.05

17.

SH4

13.670.56

13.850.57

14.040.58

1.036

1.019

2.055

1.351

1.333

2.684

<0.05

18.

SH6

17.540.82

17.900.83

18.250.85

1.346

1.322

2.668

1.985

1.946

3.931

<0.05

19.

SH7

5.950.26

6.070.26

6.190.27

1.458

1.426

2.883

1.990

1.951

3.941

<0.05

20.

SH10

1.980.09

2.020.09

2.050.09

1.165

1.151

2.316

1.646

1.620

3.266

<0.05

21.

SH11

4.130.10

4.180.13

4.220.15

1.158

0.931

2.029

1.000

0.990

1.990

<0.05

22.

SH12

1.480.06

1.500.06

1.520.06

1.038

1.043

2.081

1.301

1.285

2.586

<0.05

23.

SH13

25.751.22

26.101.08

26.450.94

0.959

1.092

2.029

1.351

1.333

2.684

<0.05

Nhóm

Chỉ số, test

Ban đầu

x (1)

Sau 6 tháng

x (2)

Sau 12 tháng

x (3)

t1,2

t2,3

t1,3

W1,2

W2,3

W1,3

P

24.

Sư phạm

TLC1

4.630.12

4.580.16

4.520.21

1.171

0.898

1.982

1.141

1.155

2.296

<0.05

25.

TLC4

76.722.02

75.892.57

75.063.11

1.134

0.920

1.999

1.086

1.098

2.184

<0.05

26.

TLC6

6.680.18

6.610.22

6.530.26

1.154

0.951

2.056

1.101

1.113

2.214

<0.05

27.

TLCM1

60.401.60

59.821.76

59.241.92

1.085

0.991

2.065

0.960

0.969

1.928

<0.05

28.

TLCM2

13.350.36

13.210.43

13.060.51

1.154

0.961

2.072

1.091

1.103

2.194

<0.05

29.

TLCM3

8.200.22

8.280.27

8.370.31

1.113

0.930

2.002

1.035

1.024

2.059

<0.05

30.

TLCM7

12.550.34

12.430.37

12.310.40

1.078

0.989

2.057

0.960

0.969

1.928

<0.05

31.

TLCM9

18.440.48

18.220.65

18.010.82

1.196

0.928

2.040

1.182

1.196

2.378

<0.05

32.

TLCM14

27.520.73

27.820.93

28.131.14

1.153

0.929

2.023

1.104

1.092

2.196

<0.05

33.

TLCM18

29.320.77

29.050.85

28.770.93

1.080

0.982

2.050

0.949

0.959

1.908

<0.05

34.

TLCM19

26.300.69

26.010.85

25.721.01

1.169

0.968

2.090

1.096

1.108

2.204

<0.05

35.

TLCM24

98.922.61

100.113.51

101.314.40

1.224

0.952

2.093

1.203

1.188

2.391

<0.05

36.

KT1

15.440.40

15.620.49

15.800.58

1.264

1.060

2.280

1.158

1.145

2.303

<0.05

37.

KT2

14.550.38

14.720.46

14.890.53

1.260

1.079

2.304

1.148

1.135

2.284

<0.05

38.

KT3

6.660.18

6.740.23

6.810.28

1.189

0.949

2.073

1.153

1.140

2.293

<0.05

39.

KT4

5.670.15

5.740.19

5.800.24

1.149

0.908

1.988

1.099

1.087

2.186

<0.05

40.

KT11

6.660.18

6.740.25

6.820.32

1.183

0.896

1.983

1.203

1.188

2.391

<0.05

41.

KT22

6.660.18

6.740.24

6.810.29

1.149

0.898

1.972

1.134

1.121

2.254

<0.05

42.

KT23

15.540.41

15.740.56

15.930.71

1.256

0.970

2.136

1.252

1.237

2.489

<0.05

43.

CT1

26.700.70

26.430.83

26.170.96

1.095

0.938

2.002

1.000

1.010

2.010

<0.05

44.

CT5

6.660.18

6.740.23

6.810.28

1.184

0.945

2.064

1.148

1.135

2.284

<0.05

45.

CT6

15.540.41

15.730.54

15.910.66

1.225

0.977

2.134

1.188

1.174

2.362

<0.05

46.

Tâm lý

TL1

168.524.45

166.875.25

165.226.05

1.073

0.922

1.967

0.985

0.995

1.979

<0.05

47.

TL2

297.287.84

294.359.08

291.4310.32

1.091

0.953

2.021

0.990

1.000

1.990

<0.05

48.

TL3

1.900.05

1.920.06

1.940.06

1.185

1.050

2.214

1.035

1.024

2.059

<0.05

49.

TL7

4.250.11

4.300.15

4.350.20

1.206

0.905

2.007

1.183

1.169

2.352

<0.05

50.

TL9

21.700.57

21.960.74

22.220.90

1.260

1.012

2.206

1.203

1.188

2.391

<0.05

51.

TL11

2.640.07

2.680.08

2.710.09

1.313

1.167

2.458

1.153

1.140

2.293

<0.05

52.

TL12

0.660.02

0.670.02

0.680.03

1.150

0.991

2.112

1.178

1.164

2.342

<0.05

53.

TL13

47.221.24

47.771.67

48.322.10

1.177

0.914

2.010

1.153

1.140

2.293

<0.05

54.

TL14

42.691.12

43.181.42

43.671.72

1.200

0.975

2.118

1.134

1.121

2.254

<0.05

W trung bình

1.256

1.244

2.500

Hệ thống tiêu chuẩn TC

Tổng

Tiêu chuẩn TC của luận án (n = 20)

Tiêu chuẩn TC áp dụng tại các đơn vị (n = 20)

Tốt

12

8

20

10.000

10.000

Khá

8

3

11

5.500

5.500

Trung bình

0

5

5

2.500

2.500

Yếu

0

3

3

1.500

1.500

Kém

0

1

1

0.500

0.500

Tổng

20

20

40

So sánh

2tính = 8.073 > 2 .05 = 5.991 với P < 0.05

0

Hệ thống tiêu chuẩn TC

Tổng

Tiêu chuẩn TC của luận án (n = 16)

Tiêu chuẩn TC áp dụng tại các đơn vị (n = 16)

Tốt

9

4

13

6.500

6.500

Khá

7

6

13

6.500

6.500

Trung bình

0

3

3

1.500

1.500

Yếu

0

2

2

1.000

1.000

Kém

0

1

1

0.500

0.500

Tổng

16

16

32

So sánh

2tính = 8.000 > 2 .05 = 5.991 với P < 0.05

0