Ảnh hưởng của hình thức sở hữu nhà nước đến tỷ suất sinh lời của các Ngân hàng thương mại cổ phần Việt Nam - 11



13


2009


8.85%


0


18.37%


1.05%


42.11%


16.36


80.54%


77.76%


5.32%


6.88%


13


2010


9.70%


0


15.95%


0.90%


40.06%


16.80


58.84%


52.49%


6.78%


9.19%


13


2011


8.07%


0


14.76%


1.26%


47.17%


17.05


54.46%


45.19%


5.89%


18.58%


13


2012


6.02%


0


13.93%


1.81%


47.87%


17.13


62.86%


64.70%


5.03%


9.21%


13


2013


6.09%


0


12.09%


1.02%


49.79%


17.31


61.53%


66.30%


5.42%


6.60%


13


2014


5.49%


0


10.28%


1.42%


52.80%


17.48


54.90%


68.13%


5.98%


4.09%


14


2007


14.13%


0


11.75%


1.24%


34.23%


17.20


39.20%


68.03%


8.48%


8.30%


14


2008


15.90%


0


9.98%


1.57%


33.91%


17.61


35.49%


68.04%


6.23%


22.90%


14


2009


15.89%


0


9.98%


1.51%


29.55%


18.05


42.88%


64.36%


5.32%


6.88%


14


2010


19.28%


0


8.10%


1.51%


30.67%


18.51


44.51%


65.26%


6.78%


9.19%


14


2011


19.86%


0


6.95%


1.85%


36.54%


18.75


42.53%


69.32%


5.89%


18.58%


14


2012


18.04%


0


7.33%


1.76%


34.51%


18.98


42.41%


72.35%


5.03%


9.21%


14


2013


15.09%


0


8.40%


2.02%


35.85%


19.01


48.64%


82.36%


5.42%


6.60%


14


2014


15.11%


0


8.26%


2.45%


37.49%


19.12


50.16%


91.13%


5.98%


4.09%


15


2007


14.15%


0


5.55%


0.79%


43.88%


17.49


42.60%


47.64%


8.48%


8.30%


15


2008


7.36%


0


6.60%


0.94%


66.60%


17.36


56.96%


73.72%


6.23%


22.90%


15


2009


15.60%


0


5.20%


0.91%


54.52%


17.85


48.30%


60.28%


5.32%


6.88%


15


2010


12.00%


0


7.03%


1.13%


46.99%


18.36


44.48%


51.57%


6.78%


9.19%


15


2011


7.83%


0


8.42%


1.58%


48.20%


18.39


44.87%


49.72%


5.89%


18.58%

15

2012

6.22%

0

12.87%

1.69%

55.70%

17.99

52.12%

68.95%

5.03%

9.21%

Có thể bạn quan tâm!

Xem toàn bộ 90 trang tài liệu này.

Ảnh hưởng của hình thức sở hữu nhà nước đến tỷ suất sinh lời của các Ngân hàng thương mại cổ phần Việt Nam - 11



15


2013


0.63%


0


10.38%


2.63%


62.12%


18.16


45.84%


62.76%


5.42%


6.60%


15


2014


6.15%


0


10.54%


2.33%


47.08%


18.21


47.33%


67.98%


5.98%


4.09%


16


2007


11.91%


0


14.06%


0.85%


29.72%


16.14


72.30%


73.88%


8.48%


8.30%


16


2008


10.97%


0


13.12%


0.91%


40.74%


16.23


70.65%


73.59%


6.23%


22.90%


16


2009


10.86%


0


16.29%


1.25%


37.97%


16.29


81.86%


85.32%


5.32%


6.88%


16


2010


22.55%


0


20.97%


1.40%


22.71%


16.64


62.19%


68.25%


6.78%


9.19%


16


2011


7.79%


0


25.73%


2.12%


34.97%


16.52


74.84%


80.82%


5.89%


18.58%


16


2012


10.75%


0


23.83%


1.01%


36.43%


16.51


73.13%


92.39%


5.03%


9.21%


16


2013


8.49%


0


23.84%


0.95%


22.59%


16.50


72.66%


96.59%


5.42%


6.60%


16


2014


5.19%


0


22.03%


0.83%


40.21%


16.58


70.99%


96.80%


5.98%


4.09%


17


2007


19.02%


0


11.38%


0.50%


30.36%


17.98


54.79%


77.30%


8.48%


8.30%


17


2008


12.31%


0


11.34%


0.72%


51.75%


18.04


51.15%


76.02%


6.23%


22.90%


17


2009


15.84%


0


10.14%


0.86%


40.01%


18.46


57.35%


64.74%


5.32%


6.88%


17


2010


13.63%


0


9.20%


0.99%


43.07%


18.84


54.13%


56.61%


6.78%


9.19%


17


2011


13.72%


0


10.28%


1.01%


53.13%


18.77


56.93%


59.16%


5.89%


18.58%


17


2012


7.32%


0


9.01%


1.50%


60.62%


18.84


63.33%


77.63%


5.03%


9.21%


17


2013


13.06%


0


10.57%


0.20%


55.33%


18.90


68.51%


91.22%


5.42%


6.60%


17


2014


12.22%


0


9.52%


0.04%


54.07%


19.06


67.45%


94.94%


5.98%


4.09%


18


2007


11.05%


0


14.02%


0.37%


31.16%


16.06


60.88%


56.23%


8.48%


8.30%

18

2008

4.87%

0

14.36%

0.90%

54.66%

16.15

64.29%

84.30%

6.23%

22.90%



18


2009


12.25%


0


10.84%


1.01%


38.74%


16.58


76.13%


76.65%


5.32%


6.88%


18


2010


7.85%


0


14.10%


1.50%


41.99%


17.00


55.19%


45.41%


6.78%


9.19%


18


2011


6.94%


0


15.88%


1.64%


50.54%


16.93


51.43%


38.27%


5.89%


18.58%


18


2012


4.64%


0


14.36%


1.53%


59.30%


17.02


52.38%


71.16%


5.03%


9.21%


18


2013


1.68%


0


13.27%


1.34%


76.36%


17.11


53.23%


80.28%


5.42%


6.60%


18


2014


1.31%


0


10.22%


1.19%


82.74%


17.39


44.46%


61.90%


5.98%


4.09%


19


2007


7.53%


0


11.61%


0.20%


28.06%


15.36


40.96%


31.70%


8.48%


8.30%


19


2008


6.39%


0


16.59%


0.75%


48.65%


15.64


38.25%


42.63%


6.23%


22.90%


19


2009


16.00%


0


10.50%


0.75%


36.57%


16.16


60.15%


73.95%


5.32%


6.88%


19


2010


10.07%


0


13.27%


0.97%


42.53%


16.61


66.47%


75.36%


6.78%


9.19%


19


2011


17.22%


0


14.74%


1.52%


38.76%


16.68


68.89%


72.88%


5.89%


18.58%


19


2012


7.51%


0


16.59%


2.31%


48.07%


16.77


71.62%


76.80%


5.03%


9.21%


19


2013


1.19%


0


12.90%


1.35%


69.94%


17.03


55.74%


63.98%


5.42%


6.60%


19


2014


3.92%


0


12.95%


1.19%


63.84%


17.07


56.27%


80.23%


5.98%


4.09%


20


2007


7.36%


0


18.67%


0.40%


34.79%


17.33


54.74%


83.55%


8.48%


8.30%


20


2008


5.54%


0


26.62%


1.77%


31.85%


17.69


44.01%


87.22%


6.23%


22.90%


20


2009


8.48%


0


20.40%


0.99%


35.20%


18.00


58.64%


74.41%


5.32%


6.88%


20


2010


13.43%


0


10.30%


1.01%


27.98%


18.69


47.55%


49.45%


6.78%


9.19%


20


2011


18.64%


0


8.88%


0.83%


30.62%


19.03


40.67%


32.08%


5.89%


18.58%

20

2012

13.53%

0

9.29%

0.81%

42.64%

18.95

44.03%

45.65%

5.03%

9.21%



20


2013


4.49%


0


8.64%


0.85%


65.28%


18.95


49.08%


51.22%


5.42%


6.60%


20


2014


0.40%


0


8.73%


1.17%


69.62%


18.90


54.10%


68.95%


5.98%


4.09%

Ghi chú:


1

NHTMCP Ngoại thương Việt Nam

2

NHTMCP Công thương Việt Nam

3

NHTMCP Đầu tư và phát triển Việt Nam

4

NHTMCP Á Châu

5

NHTMCP Đông Á

6

NHTMCP Đông Nam Á

7

NHTMCP An Bình

8

NHTMCP Hàng Hải

9

NHTMCP Kiên Long

10

NHTMCP Nam Á

11

NHTMCP Quốc Dân

12

NHTMCP Phát triển TP. Hồ Chí Minh

13

NHTMCP Phương Đông

14

NHTMCP Quân Đội

15

NHTMCP Quốc tế

16

NHTMCP Sài Gòn Công Thương

17

NHTMCP Sài Gòn Thương Tín

18

NHTMCP Việt Á

19

NHTMCP Ngân hàng Xăng dầu Việt Nam

20

NHTMCP Xuất nhập khẩu Việt Nam


Phụ lục 2: Kết qủa thống kê mô tả

Variable | Mean Std. Dev. Min Max | Observations

-----------------+--------------------------------------------+---------------- ROE overall | .1007704 .0600582 .0025326 .2846444 | N = 160


between

|

.0393976

.0510614

.1827625

|

n

=

20

within

|

.0460776

-.0198872

.2157545

|

T

=

8


|




|




CAP

overall

| .1134918

.0556759

.0425561

.3563394

|

N

=

160


between

|

.0439551

.0576877

.2172989

|

n

=

20


within

|

.0353952

.0385669

.2652592

|

T

=

8



|




|




CR

overall

| .0129436

.0068728

.0003834

.0370178

|

N

=

160


between

|

.0049861

.0065599

.0270117

|

n

=

20


within

|

.0048445

.0007231

.0252844

|

T

=

8



|




|





OC

overall

|

.4822025

.150778

.1881495

.9835238

|

N

=

160


between

|


.0751498

.3316604

.6470516

|

n

=

20


within

|


.131663

.1615489

.9099147

|

T

=

8



|





|




Size

overall

|

17.77316

1.252451

14.60436

20.30946

|

N

=

160


between

|


1.155487

16.11814

19.74014

|

n

=

20


within

|


.5406128

16.25938

18.85624

|

T

=

8



|





|




LA

overall

|

.5301676

.1350489

.1942878

.8516832

|

N

=

160


between

|


.114964

.3049152

.7232703

|

n

=

20


within

|


.0748555

.3396922

.7286218

|

T

=

8



|





|




DOP

overall

|

.6554604

.151082

.0352015

.9779813

|

N

=

160


between

|


.0794609

.4794919

.8345456

|

n

=

20


within

|


.1295751

.0387942

.9893569

|

T

=

8



|





|




GDP

overall

|

.0614125

.0102817

.0503

.0848

|

N

=

160


between

|


0

.0614125

.0614125

|

n

=

20


within

|


.0102817

.0503

.0848

|

T

=

8



|





|




CPI

overall

|

.1071875

.0610481

.0409

.229

|

N

=

160


between

|


1.42e-17

.1071875

.1071875

|

n

=

20


within

|


.0610481

.0409

.229

|

T

=

8



|





|




OWN

overall

|

.15

.3581925

0

1

|

N

=

160


between

|


.3663475

0

1

|

n

=

20


within

|


0

.15

.15

|

T

=

8


Phụ lục 3: Ma trận tương quan


| ROE OWN CAP CR OC Size LA

-------------+---------------------------------------------------------------

ROE

|

1.0000





OWN

|

0.2977

1.0000



CAP

|

-0.3577

-0.3532

1.0000


CR

|

-0.0464

0.4479

-0.2506

1.0000

OC

|

-0.6609

-0.1611

-0.0284

0.1281

1.0000



Size

|

0.3665

0.6421

-0.6766

0.4901

-0.0242

1.0000


LA

|

0.0512

0.2654

0.2549

-0.0923

-0.1006

-0.0824

1.0000

DOP

|

-0.1110

0.0885

0.1642

0.1634

0.1660

0.1031

0.5033

GDP

|

0.2062

-0.0000

0.0207

-0.3226

-0.3676

-0.2410

-0.0487

CPI

|

0.1249

-0.0000

0.1815

-0.0376

-0.0556

-0.1494

-0.0346


|

DOP

GDP

CPI





-------------+--------------------------- DOP | 1.0000

GDP | -0.2618 1.0000

CPI | -0.1818 0.0269 1.0000


Phụ lục 4: Kết quả hồi quy OLS


Source | SS df MS

Number of obs

=

160

-------------+------------------------------

F( 14, 145)

=

24.05

Model | .400873553 14 .028633825

Prob > F

=

0.0000

Residual | .172636874 145 .001190599

R-squared

=

0.6990



-------------+------------------------------ Adj R-squared = 0.6699 Total | .573510428 159 .003606984 Root MSE = .03451


------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ROE | Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]

-------------+----------------------------------------------------------------

OWN

|

-.012694

.0132605

-0.96

0.340

-.0389029

.013515

CAP

|

-.2776458

.0765447

-3.63

0.000

-.4289332

-.1263583

CR

|

-1.245674

.5226777

-2.38

0.018

-2.278725

-.2126228

OC

|

-.2081536

.0233313

-8.92

0.000

-.254267

-.1620403

Size

|

.0179866

.0047798

3.76

0.000

.0085395

.0274338

LA

|

.0193322

.0291279

0.66

0.508

-.0382379

.0769022

DOP

|

.0437012

.0262121

1.67

0.098

-.008106

.0955084

GDP

|

.7548632

.5426453

1.39

0.166

-.3176532

1.82738

CPI

|

.5782744

.3658995

1.58

0.116

-.1449111

1.30146


|







year

|







2008

|

-.0543875

.0621287

-0.88

0.383

-.1771823

.0684073

2009

|

.0419028

.0130817

3.20

0.002

.0160474

.0677582

2010

|

.0218176

.013324

1.64

0.104

-.0045168

.0481519

2011

|

-.0294535

.0474544

-0.62

0.536

-.1232452

.0643382

2012

|

.0061073

.0185991

0.33

0.743

-.0306531

.0428678

2013

|

0

(omitted)





2014

|

0

(omitted)






|







_cons

|

-.2144821

.1136234

-1.89

0.061

-.4390541

.01009


Phụ lục 5: Kiểm định Hausman Test


---- Coefficients ----

| (b) (B) (b-B) sqrt(diag(V_b-V_B))

| FEM REM Difference S.E.

-------------+----------------------------------------------------------------

CAP

|

-.3514255

-.3302843

-.0211412

.0352588

CR

|

-.8229315

-1.013048

.1901163

.2941803

OC

|

-.2354753

-.2473175

.0118422

.0106045

Size

|

.0052652

.0118472

-.006582

.0055418

GDP

|

-.1744214

-.0061071

-.1683143

.1290418

CPI

|

.1502564

.1738526

-.0235962

.0149282

LA

|

.0010313

.0276804

-.0266491

.0237863

DOP

|

-.026687

-.0087474

-.0179395

.0069601

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

b = consistent under Ho and Ha; obtained from xtreg B = inconsistent under Ha, efficient under Ho; obtained from xtreg

Test: Ho: difference in coefficients not systematic chi2(8) = (b-B)'[(V_b-V_B)^(-1)](b-B)

= 3.60

Prob>chi2 = 0.8913

(V_b-V_B is not positive definite)



Phụ lục 6: kiểm định Breusch-Pagan


Breusch and Pagan Lagrangian multiplier test for random effects ROE[id,t] = Xb + u[id] + e[id,t]

Estimated results:

| Var sd = sqrt(Var)

---------+-----------------------------


ROE |

.003607

.0600582

e |

.0010297

.0320883


Test:

u |


Var(u) = 0

.0002598

.0161171

chibar2(01) = 19.75

Prob > chibar2 = 0.0000

Phụ lục 7: Kết quả hồi quy RE

Random-effects GLS regression Number of obs = 160

Group variable: id Number of groups = 20

R-sq: within = 0.5913 Obs per group: min = 8

between = 0.7203 avg = 8.0

overall = 0.6437 max = 8

Wald chi2(9) = 239.72

corr(u_i, X) = 0 (assumed) Prob > chi2 = 0.0000


------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ROE | Coef. Std. Err. z P>|z| [95% Conf. Interval]

-------------+----------------------------------------------------------------

OWN

|

-.0053315

.0180744

-0.29

0.768

-.0407567

.0300937

CAP

|

-.3302843

.0818599

-4.03

0.000

-.4907266

-.1698419

CR

|

-1.013048

.5811071

-1.74

0.081

-2.151997

.1259011

OC

|

-.2473175

.0219816

-11.25

0.000

-.2904007

-.2042343

Size

|

.0118472

.005487

2.16

0.031

.0010928

.0226015

LA

|

.0276804

.0341576

0.81

0.418

-.0392672

.0946281

DOP

|

-.0087474

.0245278

-0.36

0.721

-.0568211

.0393263

GDP

|

-.0061071

.3244905

-0.02

0.985

-.6420967

.6298825

CPI

|

.1738526

.0460435

3.78

0.000

.0836089

.2640963

_cons

|

.0336613

.1161386

0.29

0.772

-.1939661

.2612887

-------------+----------------------------------------------------------------

sigma_u | .01611711

sigma_e | .03208834

rho | .20145549 (fraction of variance due to u_i)


Phụ lục 8: Kết quả hồi quy SGMM


Dynamic panel-data estimation, two-step system GMM

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Group variable: id

Number of obs =

160

Time variable : year

Number of groups =

20

Number of instruments = 24

Obs per group: min =

8


F(10, 19)

=

42.50

avg =

8.00

Prob > F

=

0.000

max =

8

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

|


Corrected


ROE |

Coef.

Std. Err.

t

P>|t|

[95% Conf. Interval]

-------------+----------------------------------------------------------------

OWN

|

-.0330289

.0157739

-2.09

0.050

-.0660442

-.0000137

Size

|

.0279164

.0071857

3.88

0.001

.0128765

.0429562

OC

|

-.2343284

.0473131

-4.95

0.000

-.3333559

-.1353009

CR

|

-1.069963

.8693362

-1.23

0.233

-2.889504

.749579

CAP

|

-.1907292

.1496134

-1.27

0.218

-.5038736

.1224152

LA

|

.033349

.043257

0.77

0.450

-.0571888

.1238869

DOP

|

.0272163

.0292984

0.93

0.365

-.034106

.0885386

GDP

|

-.4150709

.3263777

-1.27

0.219

-1.098187

.2680454

CPI

|

.1045981

.0563248

1.86

0.079

-.0132909

.2224872

year

|

-.0068228

.0021862

-3.12

0.006

-.0113986

-.0022471

_cons

|

13.45304

4.363178

3.08

0.006

4.320802

22.58528

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Instruments for first differences equation Standard

D.(OWN Size OC CR LA DOP GDP CPI year)

GMM-type (missing=0, separate instruments for each period unless collapsed) L.CAP

Instruments for levels equation Standard

OWN Size OC CR LA DOP GDP CPI year

_cons

GMM-type (missing=0, separate instruments for each period unless collapsed) D.CAP

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Arellano-Bond test for AR(1) in first differences: z = -2.39 Pr > z = 0.017 Arellano-Bond test for AR(2) in first differences: z = -0.56 Pr > z = 0.578

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sargan test of overid. restrictions: chi2(13) = 61.42 Prob > chi2 = 0.000 (Not robust, but not weakened by many instruments.)

Hansen test of overid. restrictions: chi2(13) = 9.69 Prob > chi2 = 0.719 (Robust, but weakened by many instruments.)


Difference-in-Hansen tests of exogeneity of instrument subsets:

Hansen test excluding group: chi2(6)

=

4.16

Prob

>

chi2

=

0.655

Difference (null H = exogenous): chi2(7)

=

5.52

Prob

>

chi2

=

0.597

Hansen test excluding group: chi2(4)

=

5.61

Prob

>

chi2

=

0.230

Difference (null H = exogenous): chi2(9)

=

4.08

Prob

>

chi2

=

0.906

GMM instruments for levels


iv(OWN Size OC CR LA DOP GDP CPI year)

..... Xem trang tiếp theo?
⇦ Trang trước - Trang tiếp theo ⇨

Ngày đăng: 07/06/2022