Mai Hich Destination Sustainability Assessment Table

Index

Unit/value of comparison

Value of destination

Point

Source of evidence

4. Level of service provision

Tourist/local population ratio

Average annual growth rate

2%

1

Social Economic Situation Report

Chieng Chau 2013-2019

5. Tourist satisfaction

Tourist satisfaction level

74% (SAT4)

3

Investigation results

6. Change

cultural change

- society

Percentage of local people speaking a non-local language

30% (youth + children in the process of studying, working)

4

Survey results

Rate of change in traditional activities and customs

The average rate is about 45%.

- There are signs of change in clothing: only worn on festivals and events.

- Language, rituals, religion: changed and are being restored.

- Thai cuisine changes closer to Kinh and Western cuisine.

- The village's rules are gradually not being strictly followed by the people.

3

Survey results

Percentage of local people concerned about the loss of cultural community structure and traditional values

5%

5

Survey results

The proportion of new construction in vernacular architecture or considered incompatible with structures and traditions

40%

1

Survey results

Index

Unit/value of comparison

Value of destination

Point

Source of evidence

7. Local participation in community tourism development

Level of local community participation in tourism planning

30%

2

Survey results

Level of community consensus on tourism activities

An estimated 90% of people support it.

5

Survey results

Local people's satisfaction with tourism activities

% of people reporting satisfaction

90%

5

Survey results

Local security and socio-political situation

No incidents reported

3

Social Economic Situation Report

Chieng Chau 2013-2019

8. Approach

destination

Accessibility to local tourism information

- There is a common website for the district and province, but the information is not updated regularly and is not easy to look up.

- Households ask relatives to set up Facebook, fanpages, and websites to advertise and post news. This is just a spontaneous activity, implemented by households themselves.

3

Survey results

Infrastructure, destination accessibility, transportation and access

Access by car, motorbike, time: 3 hours from Hanoi

3

Survey results

III. Environmental protection

1. Solid waste management

Waste collection rate and collection situation of tourist facilities

- About 60-70% of waste is collected, dried, burned and buried.

- Some automatic databases

waste collection and

3

Survey results

Index

Unit/value of comparison

Value of destination

Point

Source of evidence

go out into the ravine, streamside ...

Situation of waste collection service provision by local authorities

The government arranged 2 cars to collect garbage, collect once every 2 days, the garbage collected is almost not all, it is saved for the following days.

3

Survey results

Waste treatment and recycling situation

- Waste is collected to a collection point to be dried, burned, and buried.

- No Waste treatment and recycling plant

2

Survey results

Propaganda work on toxic waste: training, introduction to harmful effects and collection methods

Mai Chau district opens training classes, instructing on identification, harm, classification and collection methods every year

4

Social Economic Report

Chieng Chau 2013-2019

Survey results

Percentage of garbage collected on streets and public places

Basically collected, there is still littering, not in the right place. Estimated: 60%

3

Survey results

Keep the destination's image clean

4.19 (ENV6)

2

Tourist survey and research results

Local community and visitor awareness of public littering levels

4.14 (EVN1)

3

Tourist survey and research results

2. Wastewater management

Collection and treatment of all types of wastewater; wastewater is recycled for other purposes.

- Household wastewater is only filtered through settling tanks and septic tanks and discharged into the environment.

- Some households discharge directly into the environment, rivers and streams.

1

Survey results

Index

Unit/value of comparison

Value of destination

Point

Source of evidence

- Proportion of tourism businesses and residents in the area with wastewater treatment systems

Household wastewater is only filtered through settling tanks and septic tanks and discharged into the environment.

1

Survey results

Number of pollution events per year

There is no pollution due to tourism; there is only pollution due to local production and business activities.

3

Social Economic Situation Report

Chieng Chau 2013-2019

The extent to which local rivers, streams, and lakes are polluted by waste

- Wastewater is discharged into rivers and streams but not at a level of pollution that can be observed and felt with the naked eye.

1

Survey results

3. Erosion

- Percentage of surface eroded by tourism activities

- Percentage of surface area free of trees and bushes

Normal (about 10%)

5

Survey results (Reporter of Commune Leader)

4. Visual pollution

Percentage of slope in community with no visible trees or shrubs

Normal (about 10%)

5

Survey results (Reporter of Commune Leader)

5. Noise pollution

Noise pollution levels: tourist complaints, tourist acceptability

3.63 (EVN4)

3

Tourist survey and research results

Average score:

3.14

Index

Unit/value of comparison

Value of destination

Point

Source of evidence

I. Economic development

1. Economic benefits

Revenue from operations

tourist attraction

Average annual growth rate

168%

5

BC of CBT Mai Hich 2013-2019

Average household income

Average annual growth rate

11%

4

Report on Socio-economic situation of Mai Hich commune 2013-2019

Number of locally owned enterprises/Total enterprises in the area?

Average annual growth rate

32%

4

BC of CBT Mai Hich 2013-2019

Number of tourists

Average annual growth rate

139%

5

BC of CBT Mai Hich 2013-2019

Average visitor spending

Cost/day stay

500,000 VND -

600,000 VND

4

BC of CBT Mai Hich 2013-2019

Average number of days of stay

1.9

2

BC of CBT Mai Hich 2013-2019

Net economic benefit to the community

4.36 (ECO5)

4

- Survey results

- Report of World Tourism Organization (UNWTO) and Griffth university, Managing Growth and Sustainable Tourism Governance in Asia and the Pacific, 2017

II. Social development

1. Local poverty situation

Poverty rate

Average annual reduction rate

-4.43%

4

Report on Socio-economic situation of Mai Hich commune 2013-2019

Index

Unit/value of comparison

Value of destination

Point

Source of evidence

2. Employment

Employment rate from tourism

Average annual growth rate

51.40%

5

Report on Socio-economic situation of Mai Hich commune 2013-2019

3. Infrastructure and services

Level of investment in infrastructure or services

Average investment/year

1453

3

- Report on Socio-economic situation of Mai Hich commune 2013-2019

http://danviet.vn/nha-nong/nguoi-dan-mai-hich-gop-hon-2-ty-dong-xay-dung-nong- thon-moi- 997678.html

4. Level of service provision

Tourist/local population ratio

Average annual growth rate

172%

5

Report on Socio-economic situation of Mai Hich commune 2013-2019

5. Tourist satisfaction

Tourist satisfaction level

89% (SAT4)

4

Investigation results

6. Change

cultural change

- society

Percentage of local people speaking a non-local language

30% (youth + children in the process of studying and working)

4

Survey results

Rate of change in traditional activities and customs

The average rate is about 35%.

- There are signs of change in clothing: only worn on festivals and events.

- Language, rituals, religion: changed and are being restored.

- Thai cuisine changes closer to Kinh and Western cuisine.

- Wish of

version is gradually

4

Survey results

Index

Unit/value of comparison

Value of destination

Point

Source of evidence

not strictly followed by the people.

Percentage of local people concerned about the loss of cultural community structure and traditional values

7%

4

Survey results

The proportion of new construction in vernacular architecture or considered incompatible with structures and traditions

10%

3

Survey results

7. Local participation in community tourism development

Level of local community participation in tourism planning

34%

2

Survey results

Level of community consensus on tourism activities

An estimated 95% of people support it.

5

Survey results

Local people's satisfaction with tourism activities

% of people reporting satisfaction

95%

5

Survey results

Local security and socio-political situation

No incidents reported

4

CBT Travel

8. Approach

destination

Accessibility to local tourism information

Address: Homestay Mai Hich, Minh Tho homestay, CBT Mai Hich, Tripadvisor, booking, agoda, foody, dulich24h,... Easy to look up and book online

5

Survey results

Index

Unit/value of comparison

Value of destination

Point

Source of evidence

Infrastructure, destination accessibility, transportation and access

Access by car, motorbike, time: 2 hours from Hanoi

4

Survey results

III. Environmental protection

waste collected

1. Solid waste management

Percentage of waste collected

collection and collection situation of tourist facilities

Collect according to regulations, in which homestays collect themselves

waste, sorting, recycling

4

Report on Socio-economic situation of Mai Hich commune 2013-2019

calendar

use bottles, boxes;

burn and bury

Survey results

About 80%

Situation of waste collection service provision by local authorities

The government arranged 2 cars to collect garbage.

4

Report on Socio-economic situation of Mai Hich commune 2013-2019

Survey results

Garbage is collected

Socio-economic situation report

Treatment and recycling status

waste

gather at the gathering place

to dry, burn,

4

Mai Hich commune 2013-

2019

burial

Survey results

Propaganda work on toxic waste: training, introduction to harmful effects and collection methods

Mai Chau district opens training classes, instructing on identification, harm, classification and collection methods every year

4

Report on Socio-economic situation of Mai Hich commune 2013-2019

Survey results

Percentage of garbage collected on streets and public places

Collected and kept clean.

Approximately 80%

4

Survey results

Keep the destination's image clean

4.27 (ENV6)

4

Tourist survey and research results

Community awareness

local and tourist

customer on discharge level

4.02 (EVN1)

4

Investigation results

Tourists and Surveys

public trash