Unified Definition of Clinical Conditions Leading to Organ Failure

19


Although these mechanisms are protective, the systemic response to surgery can lead to SIRS (Figure 3 - Appendix 2) [62], [91], [156].

The stress response to surgery and THNCT is characterized by increased secretion of stress hormones (adrenaline and cortisol, …) [91], [108]. This response is more severe in neonates than in older patients [108].

Stress hormones may be involved in the pathogenesis of postoperative infection and organ dysfunction. Hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis activation is required to respond to severe stress, but excessive cortisol may delay wound healing by promoting catabolism, inhibiting MD, and infection [107].

In addition, sex hormones also have important interactions with the MD system and modulate inflammatory responses [78], [155]. However, clinical trials on the role of sex hormones have shown conflicting results [78].

1.2.3.2. Stages of progression in the inflammatory response

Regarding the pathogenesis of SIRS, based on Bone's proposal (3-stage progression model), the inflammatory response is divided into 4 stages (Table 1.1) [78].

Table 1.1. Phases of the inflammatory response


Stage

Characteristic

Expression

1

Local inflammatory response

Swelling, heat, redness, pain


2

Acute phase inflammatory response (inflammatory mediators)

into the blood)

- Test : inflammatory response can be detected by testing

- Clinical: “SIRS criteria”

3

Severe systemic inflammatory syndrome (SIRS)

Severe homeostasis disorders

4

Excessive systemic response

Systemic MD inhibition

MODS

Maybe you are interested!

Unified Definition of Clinical Conditions Leading to Organ Failure

* Source: according to Faist E. (2008) [ 78]

1.2.3.3. Systemic inflammatory response syndrome

The official definition of SIRS is a systemic inflammatory response to multiple severe clinical events manifested by at least 2 of 4 criteria:


1) Hyperthermia or hypothermia, 2) Tachycardia, 3) Rapid breathing or hyperventilation,

4) Increased or decreased white blood cells ( Table 1.2) [47], [145].

Table 1.2. Unified definition of clinical conditions leading to organ failure

1. Infection : inflammatory response to the presence of microorganisms or microbial invasion of host tissue (usually sterile) .

2. Bacteremia : presence of living bacteria in the blood.

3. SIRS: when there are at least 2 of the following symptoms:

- Body temperature > 38 0 C or < 36 0 C

- Pulse > 90 beats/minute

- Respiratory rate > 20 times/minute or PaCO 2 < 32 mmHg

- BC > 12 x 10 9 /l, < 4 x 10 9 /l or > 10% of immature forms.

4. Sepsis : SIRS caused by infection (suspected or confirmed) .

5. Severe sepsis : sepsis accompanied by at least 1 organ failure or reduced blood perfusion .

6. Septic shock : severe infection accompanied by hypotension that does not respond to adequate fluid replacement .

7. MODS: damage to ≥ two organ systems in acutely ill patients in whom homeostasis cannot be maintained without therapeutic intervention.

* Source: according to Bone RC (1992) [ 47], Goldstein B. (2005) [ 87], Levy MM (2001) [ 116] and Robertson CM (2006) [ 145]

The concept of SIRS is widely accepted by clinicians and researchers [116]. The term “MODS” was replaced by “multiple organ failure” to emphasize the reversibility and dynamic nature of this syndrome [69].

For simplicity, SIRS is divided into two types: non-infectious systemic inflammatory response such as burns, trauma, surgery, pancreatitis, etc. called SIRS and infectious systemic inflammatory response called NKH [55], [145]. SIRS and NKH have many common features. Both initiate the production of similar inflammatory mediators leading to MODS and eventually death [55].

In most cases, this inflammatory response consists of two phases: the first phase is


Early MODS

Normal

INFECTION

Late MODS

Pro-inflammatory

The predominant pro-inflammatory phase (in the first 36 hours) is regulated by the innate immune system with SIRS expression. During the next few days, the predominant anti-inflammatory phase is regulated by the adaptive immune system with MD suppression expression making the patient susceptible to infection (Figure 1.7) [82], [91], [107], [199].


Anti-inflammatory

Figure 1.7. Progression of inflammatory response

The inflammatory response consists of two phases: the first phase is characterized by a proinflammatory response (SIRS) dominated by Th2 and the two cytokines TNF-α and IL-6, which can lead to early MODS. The second phase is characterized by a anti-inflammatory response (CARS) dominated by Th2 and the cytokines IL4, IL-10, and TGF-β. The anti-inflammatory phase is characterized by inhibition of MD and can also lead to late MODS.

* Source: according to Ravat F. (2011) [ 199]

Both SIRS and infection following compensatory anti-inflammatory response syndrome (CARS) can lead to MODS. Moore (1995) described early and late MODS models (Figure 1.8) depending on the severity of the initial insult and is increasingly supported by many authors [107], [176], [199].

It is estimated that approximately one-third of inpatients, over 50% of patients in intensive care units, and over 80% of patients in outpatient units meet the criteria for SIRS [145]. Depending on the disease group, the mortality rate can be as high as 90% [118]. Although caused by many different pathologies, the mechanisms causing SIRS are similar. SIRS represents the body's response to a stimulating event rather than a direct consequence of that event [145].



Inflammatory response

MODS

“One-hit” model

SIRS

(mediated by natural MD)


Severe inflammation

“Two-hit” model Additional surgical stress Ischemia/reperfusion injury

Infection

Moderate inflammation

Time after injury

Moderate MD inhibition

Surgical injury

surgery/trauma

Severe MD inhibition


CARS

(mediated by adaptive MD)

Anti-inflammatory response

Figure 1.8. Injury models for SIRS, CARS and MODS

An initial severe injury may induce a vigorous early proinflammatory response and severe SIRS (a “one-hit” model) results in early MODS. In the “two-hit” scenario, patients with initial moderate SIRS eventually develop late MODS because of reactivation of the inflammatory response due to reoperation, I/R injury, or infection. Patients who survive early SIRS due to severe injury may develop CARS associated with postoperative infection.

* Source: according to Kimura F. (2010) [ 107]

1.3. IMMUNE AND CYTOKINE CHANGES IN INFLAMMATORY RESPONSE

1.3.1. The role of immunity in the inflammatory response

Surgical and traumatic injuries severely affect the innate and adaptive MD responses, both pro-inflammatory and anti-inflammatory [91], [107]. Any cause of stress or tissue damage is a danger signal to the MD system [55]. The danger signals are called DAMPs (danger-associated molecular patterns) including PAMP (pathogen-associated molecular-pattern) and DAMP (damage-associated molecular- pattern) or alarnin. The innate and adaptive MD responses are initiated and regulated by DAMPs via receptors that recognize these molecules (Figure 4 - Appendix


2) [55], [107]. Inflammation is the first response to DAMPs and activation of MD cells is a prerequisite for the initiation of the inflammatory response [ 55].

Many complications after cardiac surgery are associated with MD dysregulation [143]. The inflammatory response peaks on the second day and lasts for about 1 week after surgery. However, the MD response is more prolonged [139], [187], [192].

1.3.2. Immunosuppression in systemic inflammatory response syndrome

Medical literature has mentioned many MD inhibition states in SIRS and NKH. MD function is inhibited due to decreased cytokine production, increased apoptosis of lymphocytes, Th1/Th2 imbalance, appearance of regulatory T lymphocytes [55], [63], [107]. MD inhibition state due to macrophages increasing production of prostaglandin E2 (MD inhibitory factor), decreased production of IL-12, decreased antigen presentation due to decreased MHC class II, ... makes patients susceptible to infection [63], [107]. Damage to antigen presentation function lasts up to 7 days depending on the degree of damage [78]. Moreover, anti-inflammatory response tendency can be genetic, making it difficult to predict inflammatory response [103].

1.3.3. Cytokines in systemic inflammatory response

1.3.3.1. General information about cytokines

- Definition: cytokines are low molecular weight proteins that act as regulatory mediators between cells in the body, produced temporarily and locally by many types of cells but mainly immune cells during inflammatory activation, … [78], [ 102].

- Effects: cytokines have rapid, short-term effects and have many different effects (pleiotropic) but mainly aim at inflammatory responses to sites of infection, injury and facilitate wound healing [78], [100], [102]. However, cytokine secretion varies greatly between individuals [129], [170 ].

- Classification: In general, inflammatory cytokines are classified into two types:

+ Pro-inflammatory cytokines: TNF-α, IL-1, IL-6 and IL-8, …

+ Anti-inflammatory cytokines: IL-1 receptor antagonists, IL-10, IL-13, … [78], [102], [111].

- Cytokine testing

Historically, the three main methods of cytokine testing include:

24


+ Molecular assays: quantification of cytokine mRNA, ...

+ Immunoassays: quantification of cytokine proteins. ELISA is the most common test and is considered the standard method of cytokine quantification, widely used in clinical and research settings.

+ Bioassays: measure the actual biological activity of cytokines in target cells; recently, single-cell assays have been used.

Cytokine quantification is difficult because cytokines are usually secreted in lymphoid compartments or tissues rather than in blood. However, the clinical sample commonly used for cytokine quantification is blood [121], [194].

At the same time, the quantification of cytokines in plasma is also difficult due to the short half-life. For example, IL-6 exists in many forms such as monomers, dimers, multimers or has anti-IL-6 autoantibodies. Therefore, many different methods may have obstacles in quantifying IL-6 [100].

1.3.3.2. Inflammatory cytokines

Inflammatory cytokines are important factors in the development of SIRS [49], [100], [171]. The immediate postoperative balance between pro-inflammatory and anti-inflammatory responses is a determinant of the clinical course [43]. However, an excessive increase in pro-inflammatory cytokines (cytokine storm) or a decrease in anti-inflammatory response will lead to SIRS, and conversely, a predominance of anti-inflammatory cytokines will lead to CARS, which will suppress the patient's immune system and increase the risk of infection. Both SIRS and infection after CARS progression can lead to MODS [91], [171], [179]. Patients with high expression of specific cytokines are almost certain to develop severe postoperative complications [113].

Cytokine response to extracorporeal circulation

According to Landis (2009), the cytokine response to THNCT includes two distinct phases:

1) The proinflammatory phase is caused by blood contact with artificial surfaces.

2) The anti-inflammatory phase is generated by the body (homeostatic response) [111].

Proinflammatory cytokines (TNF-α, IL-1, IL-2, IL-6, IL-8) are secreted early at the start of THNCT (5 min to 2 h) [111]. TNF-α stimulates many cells

25


Cells such as cardiomyocytes, macrophages, endothelial cells, etc. secrete IL-6. Next, IL-6 stimulates the liver to synthesize acute-phase proteins. IL-6 increases further at the end of surgery, peaks in the blood from the 2nd to the 6th hour after aortic clamping, and remains high up to 24 hours after surgery [81], [89], [195]. At the same time, anti-inflammatory cytokines including IL-1 receptor antagonist (IL-1ra), IL-10, and soluble TNF receptor are also typically released from 1

- 2 hours to 24 hours after THNCT [89], [111].

TNF-α and IL-1 are early inflammatory cytokines that initiate the inflammatory response and cause fever [108]. TNF-α is often elevated after THNCT and remains elevated for up to 24 hours after THNCT. TNF-α and IL-6 are associated with reduced left ventricular contractility. IL-6 levels correlate with the severity of the inflammatory response to THNCT. In addition, polymorphisms in these inflammatory mediator genes (common in the population) make some patients more susceptible to postoperative SIRS [81], [126], [195].

1.3.3.3. Interleukin-6 and Interleukin-10

The two most studied important cytokines representing the two inflammatory phases are IL-6 and IL-10 [108], [183]. Jouan (2012) demonstrated that genetic testing focusing on the IL6-G572C and IL10-C592A single nucleotide polymorphisms could be a tool to identify patients at highest risk of poor tolerance to the inflammatory response after THNCT and to apply strategies to alleviate this response [103]. On this basis, Denizot (2012) suggested that IL-6 and IL-10 are now the master predictive control mediators of the inflammatory response after THNCT [70].

- Interleukin-6

IL-6 cytokines are produced mainly by monocytes, macrophages, and endothelial cells in response to tissue injury and inflammatory stimuli [89], [100], [199]. IL-6 production is influenced by the degree of surgical trauma and tissue damage as well as the outcome of THNCT [75]. Several studies have demonstrated that increased IL-6 is associated with a proinflammatory response after surgery.

26


cardiac surgery, is an early predictor of mortality in cardiac surgery and cardiac surgery transfusion increases IL-6. Higher IL-6 levels are associated with complications after cardiac surgery [43]. IL-6 responses are often divided into pro-inflammatory and anti-inflammatory types [89], [100].

+ Pro-inflammatory activity: IL-6 is a very sensitive marker for the degree of tissue damage and plays a role in stimulating the liver to secrete acute phase proteins. IL-6 has many effects on the immune system: activating endothelial cells leading to the attraction of WBCs to the site of inflammation, activating B cells responsible for the humoral immune response,

… [78], [89], [171], [199]. IL-6 activates blood coagulation and stimulates platelet production [100], [102]. IL-6 induces hypothermia and fever through its actions on the hypothalamus. Thus, IL-6 is a major “actor” of the acute and early adaptive phases of the inflammatory response although IL-6 also has anti-inflammatory properties [89].

+ Anti-inflammatory activity: IL-6 inhibits some acute-phase response proteases, reduces TNF and IL-1 synthesis, releases GCs that inhibit MD and promotes the release of IL-1ra and soluble TNF receptors [ 78].

+ Some other activities: IL-6 binds to the hypothalamus and causes fever. IL-6 is a “strong” stimulant of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, causing the release of cortisol. Cortisol inhibits the production of IL-6. IL-6 causes hyperglycemia. In contrast, hyperglycemia increases IL-6 levels by stimulating monocytes to produce IL-6. In addition, IL-6 also inhibits insulin signaling in liver cells and may play a role in insulin resistance in many diseases including infections [ 100].

IL-6 increases after trauma, surgery, ... and can be detected early after about 70 minutes. In the first 24 hours, IL-6 can reach its highest level and then gradually return to normal levels [78], [100]. IL-6 is present in the blood for up to 10 days after injury, so it is often used as the first measure of inflammatory activation [33], [113]. High IL-6 levels reflect the risk of death due to organ failure after trauma, hemorrhage, infection, ... [100]. At the same time, high IL-6 is significant in patients with severe acute renal failure after heart surgery.

Comment


Agree Privacy Policy *