Review of Previous Studies and Identification of Research Gaps Table 1.1-Summary of Research Works

information and lack of professional staff in the field of internal control of organizations, thereby proposing solutions to improve the above shortcomings in order to enhance the efficiency of internal control system operations for public organizations in Jordan.

[5] Research by Babatunde & Shakirat Adepeju (2013) with the topic “Stakeholders perception on the effectiveness of internal control system on financial accountability in the Nigerian public sector”. The results from the research show that the internal control system in the Nigerian public sector has a positive impact on financial accountability. Through the research results, the author recommends that the Government should apply strict penalties to increase the effectiveness of the internal control system in the Nigerian public sector; this shows that the author prioritizes the improvement of the effectiveness of the control environment factor.

[6] Research by Shakirat Adepeju Babatunde & Kabiru Isa Dandago (2014) with the topic " Internal Control System Deficiency and Capital Project Mismanagement in the Nigerian Public Sector ". The topic surveys, studies, analyzes and evaluates the current status of the internal control system on capital project management in the public sector in Nigeria, from which the author recommends strict compliance with internal control activities in all components to improve management efficiency as well as ensure community benefits.

1.2. Domestic research

[1] Ho Thi Thanh Ngoc (2010) with the research topic " Solutions to improve the effectiveness of internal control activities at Construction College No. 2" . To carry out the topic, the author used a group of qualitative research methods such as generalization, synthesis, analysis, observation, interview (using questionnaires - qualitative data). The topic applied the theory of internal control of the COSO 1992 report as a theoretical basis to study and analyze, evaluate the current situation as well as find out the causes of the shortcomings in the internal control system of Construction College No. 2, at the same time propose solutions and recommendations to improve the effectiveness of internal control activities at the school, especially focusing on the control environment; information and communication. However, the limitation of this topic is that it did not apply internal control in the direction of INTOSAI in the public sector.

[2] Nguyen Thi Hoang Anh (2012) with the research topic " Improving the control system"

internal control at Ho Chi Minh City University of Technical Education" . The topic was carried out through

through qualitative research methods. The objective of the thesis is to analyze and evaluate the current state of the internal control system at Ho Chi Minh City University of Technical Education from a practical survey, thereby proposing measures to improve the effectiveness of internal control activities at the school. By providing solutions and recommendations, it will help school leaders have better management measures to suit the continuous development of the school. Through the survey, the author shows that the school is aware of the importance of the internal control system but has not fully recognized it, so it has not fully promoted the effects of the components in the system. The assessment of the internal control system is the basis for the author to form recommendations and make appropriate and useful suggestions to perfect the internal control system to operate better. From the research results of the topic, the author recommends that from the school side, the board of directors needs to show the staff the benefits of the internal control system through their actions and attitudes so that the members of the school can feel and wholeheartedly build and operate the internal control system of the school in a synchronous manner, thereby contributing to improving the management efficiency and operational efficiency of the school.

[3] Dinh The Hung and colleagues (2013) with the topic " Internal control system in public universities in Vietnam today" . The author uses qualitative research methods, mainly through synthesizing and systematizing domestic and foreign studies on the internal control system to determine the research problem of the group. Based on the assessment of different perspectives applied in practice at public universities in Vietnam, the group of authors proposed a comprehensive approach to the internal control system with elements of the internal control system specified according to the COSO perspective. To ensure the management of activities to achieve the set goals, public universities need to build and establish a suitable and effective internal control system. The article studies different viewpoints, thereby presenting viewpoints on the internal control system in public universities and the basic elements necessary in the internal control system in public universities including: Control environment, risk assessment, accounting information system, control and monitoring procedures. For the internal control system to operate effectively and efficiently, the elements of the system must operate effectively and synchronously. In essence, the internal control system in universities is most clearly expressed in terms of form, which is the control policies and procedures. The control policies and procedures will be built and operated on its foundation, which is the control environment and the accounting information system.

Policies that are stated as control procedures will only ensure operational effectiveness.

and continuity through the risk assessment and monitoring process. Therefore, to ensure operational efficiency and achieve social goals, public universities in building an internal control system must pay synchronous attention to all five factors mentioned above.

[4] Pham Thi Hoang (2013) with the topic " Improving the internal control system at Ho Chi Minh City College of Information Technology" . By using qualitative research methods, the thesis has generalized the theory of internal control according to the Supreme Audit Organization of the International Organization (INTOSAI) applied to units in the public sector. At the same time, through surveys, statistics of actual data at the school combined with theory, the current status of the internal control system at Ho Chi Minh City College of Information Technology has been analyzed, thereby providing comments, assessments, solutions and recommendations to improve the internal control system at the school. The solutions are built in a detailed and clear manner with the establishment of new control processes suitable to the management requirements of the school corresponding to the 5 elements that make up the internal control system including Control environment; Risk assessment; Control activities; Information and communication; Monitoring; in which Control and monitoring activities are given top priority.

[5] Nguyen Thi Thu Hau (2014) with the research topic "Improving the internal control system at Bac Lieu University" . By using a group of qualitative research methods, the topic has presented the theoretical basis of the internal control system in public units updated with INTOSAI 2004. Through studying the internal control system of a number of administrative units, the author has drawn lessons from events related to the domestic internal control system in public units. To have data for analysis and assessment of the current status of the internal control system, the author used the survey method, observation combined with interviews with members of the Board of Directors; leaders of departments, divisions, and faculties in Bac Lieu University. With the existing aspects in the internal control activities of the school, the author found the causes of those shortcomings; From there, specific and appropriate solutions can be proposed to improve the internal control system for the school. In particular, the school needs to prioritize promoting operational efficiency in terms of control environment and control activities within the unit.

[6] Le Nguyen Truong An (2017) with the research topic "Some solutions to improve the internal control system of Ho Chi Minh City College of Economics and Technology". Based on the theoretical framework of the internal control system COSO 1992; INTOSAI 1992 and related theories in the world and Vietnam, and using

Quantitative research methods combined with qualitative research methods, survey

Based on the evaluation opinions of lecturers, staff and authors, the project has been implemented with the main contents:

Firstly, systematize the theory of internal control system in the public sector in general and in the education sector in particular.

Second, evaluate the current state of the internal control system by the actual internal control activities at the School and combine with survey data processed by SPSS 22.0 software to test the factors affecting the internal control system of the School. The results of testing the research model show that all independent variables have a statistically significant impact (due to Sig. < 5%). Standardized regression equation: Y = 0.463*MT + 0.370*GS + 0.391*HDKS + 0.321*DGRR + 0.215*TTTT

The above equation shows that the improvement of the internal control environment at the school is most affected by the factor "Control environment" (Beta = 0.463). At the same time, "Monitoring" is also a factor that greatly affects the improvement of the internal control environment at the school (Beta = 0.370). In addition, "Control activities" also greatly affects the improvement of the internal control environment (Beta = 0.391). In addition, the factor "Risk assessment" is also what makes the staff and school leaders feel important in improving the internal control environment (Beta = 0.321). The last factor in the model "Information and communication" is also the factor that the staff and school leaders are interested in when thinking about improving the internal control environment at the school, however, the decisive role of this factor compared to other factors is not high (Beta = 0.215).

Third, based on the advantages and disadvantages presented from the current situation at the school as well as the results of the research model verification, the author proposes solutions from orientation to specific to perfect the internal control system at Ho Chi Minh City College of Economics and Technology.

1.3. Comments on previous studies and identification of research gaps Table 1.1-Summary of research works


STT


Project name

Author, year of study

rescue


Research content

Research method

rescue


Limitations of the topic


1


The modernization of the Public Control pyramid: International trends


Sterck et al. (2005)


Internal Control Practices in the Public Sector and provides interesting findings on the internal control frameworks used in some countries that were considered pioneers at the time.


Qualitative research methods

The topic only studies and proposes general solutions for practicing internal control in the public sector without mentioning the type of activity.

specifically.


2

Effects of internal control systems on financial performance in an institution of higher learning in Uganda: A case of

Uganda


Suuna Pius Mawanda (2008)


Establishing the relationship between internal control systems and financial performance in universities in Uganda.


Qualitative research methods


The topic only mentions internal control activities for the financial sector of schools but has not studied all aspects of activities.

Maybe you are interested!

Review of Previous Studies and Identification of Research Gaps Table 1.1-Summary of Research Works

martyrs

university






3


Evaluation of Internal Control Systems: A Case Study from Uganda


Angella & Eno L. Inanga (2009)


Proposing solutions to operate an organization's internal control system with all its constituent elements will promote better effectiveness.


Qualitative and quantitative research methods

Only conduct research on public sector projects funded by the Uganda Development Bank

Africa


4

The Impact of Multiple Authorities that Conduct Internal Control on Public Fund in the Control Process in

Jordan


Rahahleh, M. (2011)

The topic investigates the current status of the internal control system of public organizations in Uganda, thereby proposing solutions to improve the above shortcomings in order to enhance the effectiveness of the internal control system for public organizations in Jordan.


Qualitative research methods


The topic only uses qualitative research methods, so the proposed solutions are not highly reliable.


5

Stakeholders perception on the effectiveness of internal control system on financial

accountability


Babatunde & Shakirat Adepeju (2013)

The internal control system in the public sector of Nigeria positively affects financial accountability, hence the author recommends that the Government should impose strict penalties to

increase efficiency


Qualitative research methods

Conduct research on internal control systems only in enhancing accountability; at the same time, the

recommendation


y in the Nigerian

public sector


of the public sector internal control system

Nigeria


macroscopic


6

Internal Control System Deficiency and Capital Project Mismanagement in the Nigerian Public

Sector


Shakirat Adepeju Babatunde & Kabiru Isa Dandago (2014)

Analyzing and evaluating the current state of the internal control system on capital project management in the public sector in Nigeria, the author recommends strict compliance with internal control activities to improve management efficiency as well as ensure the interests of the public.

community.


Qualitative research methods


Only study KSNB in ​​relation to public project management


7


Solutions to improve the effectiveness of internal control activities at Construction College No. 2


Ho Thi Thanh Ngoc (2010)


Analyze and evaluate the current situation as well as find out the causes leading to the shortcomings in the internal control system of Construction College No. 2, at the same time propose solutions and recommendations to improve the effectiveness of internal control activities at the school.


Qualitative research methods

Not applying internal control in accordance with INTOSAI guidelines

in the public sector; at the same time, the solutions are not highly reliable because the author only uses research methods.

qualitative


8

Completing the internal control system at the University of Technical Education

Ho Chi Minh City


Nguyen Thi Hoang Anh (2012)

Analyze and evaluate the current status of the internal control system at Ho Chi Minh City University of Technical Education, thereby proposing measures to improve the effectiveness of internal control activities at the school.


Qualitative research methods

The solutions are not highly reliable because the author only uses qualitative research methods.


9


Internal control system in public universities in Vietnam today


Dinh The Hung and colleagues (2013)

Based on the assessment of different perspectives applied in practice at public universities in Vietnam, the group of authors proposed a comprehensive approach to the internal control system with elements of the internal control system specified according to the perspective of

COSO


Qualitative research methods


The solutions are not highly reliable because the author only uses qualitative research methods and applies them to cases.


10

Completing the internal control system at Ho Chi Minh City College of Information Technology


Pham Thi Hoang (2013)

Analyze the current status of the internal control system at Ho Chi Minh City College of Information Technology, thereby providing comments, assessments, solutions and recommendations to improve the internal control system at

school


Qualitative research methods

The solutions are not highly reliable because the author only uses qualitative research methods and only uses

secondary data


11


Completing the internal control system at Bac Lieu University


Nguyen Thi Thu Hau (2014)


Analyze the current status of the internal control system at Bac Lieu University, thereby providing comments, assessments, solutions and recommendations to improve the internal control system at the school.


Qualitative research methods

The solutions are not highly reliable because the author only uses qualitative research methods; the author uses INTOSAI

2004 made

theoretical basis


12

Some solutions to improve the internal control system of Ho Chi Minh City College of Economics and Technology

Bright


Le Nguyen Truong An (2017)

Based on the advantages and disadvantages given from the current situation at the school as well as the results of the research model testing, the author proposes solutions from orientation to specific to perfect the internal control system at the College of Economics.

Economic - Technical HCMC


Qualitative and quantitative research methods


The author uses COSO 1992 as the theoretical basis for the topic.

Comment


Agree Privacy Policy *