Forest environment leasing policy in national parks in the northern region of Vietnam - research in Ba Vi, Tam Dao, Ben En National Parks - 28



Newly restored forest

recovery (IIA 1 )


39.5



4

Grassland, forest

bush with regenerated wood (IB, IC)

ha

16.4



5

Vacant land (IA)

ha

47.7

5.8


6

Planted forest

ha

108.4

65.2


7

Lake

ha

4




Total


252

71.0


Maybe you are interested!

Forest environment leasing policy in national parks in the northern region of Vietnam - research in Ba Vi, Tam Dao, Ben En National Parks - 28


Summary of results of calculating forest environment rental prices at Ba Vi National Park


TT

Valuation Forest

Acreage

forest

Rental price

(VND/ha/year)

Forest rent

(Tr. đ/ 50 years)

1

Khoang Xanh Tourist Area –

Fairy Stream

112

691,947

3.875

2

Thien Son - Suoi Nga Tourist Area

252

570,921

7,194

3

Da Waterfall Tourist Area

71

377,856

1.3414

4

Ao Vua Tourist Area

108

632,477

3.4154

Source: Report of Ba Vi National Park

Forest environment rental price at Ba Vi National Park


Characteristic

Acreage

rent (ha)

Price

(VND/ha/year)

Total amount

(VND million/year)

1. Thien Son - Suoi Nga

252

0.5

126

2. Suoi Tien Green Space

112

0.5

56

3. Da Waterfall

71

0.4

28.4

4. King's Pond

108

0.5

54

5. Tien Sa Lake

54

0.2

10.8

6. Suoi Mo

147

0.2

29.4

Average rental price (VND/ha/year)

409,408


Appendix 11

Comparison between Ben En National Park and Ba Vi National Park


TT

Comparison criteria

National Park

Ba Vi

National Park

Ben En

Adjustment factor

Weight

1

Location, accessibility

3

1

0.33

1

2

Infrastructure conditions

3

2

0.67

1

3

Popularity

3

2

0.67

1

4

Forest status

3

3

1.00

1

5

Biodiversity

3

3

1.00

1

6

Landscape advantage

2

2

1.00

2

7

Lake advantage

0

3

3.00

3

8

Indigenous culture

2

1

0.5

1

9

Near center/big city

3

1

0.33

1

Source: Ben En National Park Report

In the above pricing table, the rating scores are understood as: 1- low/poor; 2- average; 3- high/favorable.

Based on this assessment, the coefficient of adjustment for the rental price of forests for tourism landscape business at Ben En National Park compared to the rental price of forest environment at Ba Vi National Park is determined as follows:

The adjustment factor F is calculated by the formula:

F=0.33*1 0.67 *1 0.67 *1 1*1 1* 2 3 * 3 0.5 *1 0.33*1 = 15.5 =1.29

(1 1 1 1 1 2 3 1 1) 12

Appendix 12

Summary of budget estimates for forestry items of the National Park in 2009-2011



Silviculture category

Year 2009

Year 2010

2011

Area

area (ha)

Investment level (VND)

Area (ha)

Investment level (VND)

Area

area (ha)

Investment level (VND)

New planting

253.9

1,803,756,217

151

1,104,488,722

0

0

Special forest care

846.3

957.455.241

834.5

906.438.022

0

0

Enclosure

new

100.2

115,622,989

0

0

0

0

Transitional enclosure


200


87,116,449


289.9


80,958,844


361.6


508,549,600

Total


2,963,950,000


2,901,885,588


508,549,600

(Data source: Annual summary report of the National Park)


Developments of forest violations in 4 years 2008 - 2011


Target

2008

Year 2009

Year 2010

2011

Number of violations

44

9

6

12

Fine (VND)

60,467,000

15,350,000

12,188,000

30,900,000

(Data source: Annual summary report of the National Park)


Development of TNR in ecotourism areas after renting the environment

Unit: ha



TT


Unit name

Year 2002

2011

Compare

Forested area

DT

no forest

DT

forest

Land for infrastructure construction

DT

no forest

Rate (%)

Value

1

Ao Vua Tourist Area

107.5

0.0

107.5

0

0.0

100.0

0.0


2

Khoang Tourist Area

Green-Suoi Tien

87.8

23.4

111.2

0

0.0

126.7

23.4

3

Suoi Mo Tourist Area

5.3

142.4

145.2

2.5

0.0

2,739.6

139.9

4

Thac Da Tourist Area

65.2

5.8

68.9

2.1

0.0

105.7

3.7


5

Thien Son Tourist Area-

Nga Stream

200.1

51.9

242.4

9.6

0.0

120.1

42.3

6

Tien Sa Lake Tourist Area

54.3

0.0

54.3

0

0.0

100.0

0.0

Total

520.2

223.5

729.5

14.2

0.0

140.2

209.3

(Data source: MTR rental performance report – 2011)


Annual forest protection investment level of MTR leasing units

Unit: 1,000 VND


TT

Unit name

Labor costs

Equipment costs

Total amount

1

Ao Vua Tourist Area

80,000

35,000

115,000

2

Khoang Xanh-Suoi Tien Tourist Area

88,000

25,471

113,471

3

Suoi Mo Tourist Area

96,000

24,200

120,200

4

Thac Da Tourist Area

80,000

30,574

110,574

5

Thien Son-Suoi Nga Tourist Area

120,000

50,400

170,400

6

Tien Sa Lake Tourist Area

48,000

12,468

60,468

Total

512,000

178,113

690.113

(Data source: Documents at Ba Vi National Park)

213


Appendix 13


Budget estimate for forest environment rental from 2008-2011 at Ba Vi National Park


Unit: Million VND



TT


Unit name

Acreage


forest (ha)


Approved rental price


Forest rent in 2008

Year 2009

Year 2010

2011

Rental price is negotiable.

adjust


Forest rent

Rental price is negotiable.

adjust


Forest rent

Rental price is negotiable.

adjust


Forest rent

1

Ao Vua Tourist Area

107.5

0.5

53.75

0.582

62,565

0.60

63,909

0.59

63,495

2

Khoang Xanh-Suoi Tien Tourist Area

111.2

0.5

55.60

0.582

64,718

0.59

66,108

0.59

65,680

3

Suoi Mo Tourist Area

147.7

0.2

29.40

0.23

34,315

0.24

35,052

0.24

34,825

4

Thac Da Tourist Area

71.0

0.4

28.40

0.47

33,058

0.48

33,768

0.47

33,549

5

Thien Son-Suoi Nga Tourist Area

252.0

0.5

126

0.58

146,664

0.59

149,814

0.59

148,844

6

Tien Sa Lake Tourist Area

54.3

0.2

10.86

0.23

12,641

0.24

12,913

0.24

12,829

Total

743.4


304.09


353,968


361,563


359,222

(Data source: Ba Vi National Park documents)

214


Appendix 14


Results of forest protection and development in the first 5 years of Thien Son - Suoi Nga Tourist Area and Thac Da Tourist Area

TT

Silvicultural investment costs

Unit

Thien Son - Suoi Nga Tourist Area

Thac Da Tourist Area

I

Forest area




1

Planting area

ha

41.5

5.2

2

Forest enrichment area

ha

90.2

27.83

II

Expense




1

New planting costs

Tr.đ

559.24

32.24

2

Cost of forest enrichment

Tr.đ

223.5

104.36

3

Investment in forest fire prevention and control

Tr.đ

70.77

59.25

4

Building milestones

Tr.đ

29.92

7.32


Total

Tr.đ

883.43

203.17

(Source: MTR rental plan at Thien Son - Suoi Nga Tourist Area and Thac Da Tourist Area)

1


Appendix 15

National Park System in Vietnam


Region

Garden name

Year of establishment

Area (ha)

Location

Northern midlands and mountains

Bai Tu Long

2001

15,783

Quang Ninh

Ba Be

1992

7,610

Bac Kan

Tam Dao

1986

36,883

Vinh Phuc, Thailand

Nguyen, Tuyen Quang

Xuan Son

2002

15,048

Phu Tho

Hoang Lien

1996

38,724

Lai Chau, Lao Cai

Northern Delta

Cat Ba

1986

15,200

Hai Phong

Xuan Thuy

2003

7,100

Nam Dinh

Ba Vi

1991

6,986

Hanoi

Cuc Phuong

1966

20,000

Ninh Binh, Thanh Hoa,

Peace

North Central Coast

Ben En

1992

16,634

Thanh Hoa

Pu Mat

2001

91,113

Nghe An

Vu Quang

2002

55,029

Ha Tinh

Phong Nha-

Ke Bang

2001

200,000

Quang Binh

White Horse

1991

22,030

Thua Thien-Hue

South Central

Set

Phuoc Binh

2006

19,814

Ninh Thuan

God Mountain

2003

29,865

Ninh Thuan

Central Highlands

Chu Mom Ray

2002

56,621

Kon Tum

Kon Ka Kinh

2002

41,780

Gia Lai

Yok Don

1991

115,545

Dak Lak

Chu Yang Sin

2002

58,947

Dak Lak

Bidoup Nui Ba

2004

64,800

Lam Dong

Southeast

Cat Tien

1992

73,878

Dong Nai, Lam Dong, Binh Phuoc

Fat Bu Gia Map

2002

26,032

Binh Phuoc

Go Xa Kiln

Cool

2002

18,765

Tay Ninh

Con Dao

1993

15,043

Ba Ria-Vung Tau

Southwest

Tram Chim

1994

7,588

Dong Thap

Ca Mau Cape

2003

41,862

Ca Mau

U Minh Ha

2006

8,286

Ca Mau

Upper U Minh

2002

8,053

Kien Giang

Phu Quoc

2001

31,422

Kien Giang

Source: General Department of Forestry - Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development

Comment


Agree Privacy Policy *